In a Monday court filing, attorneys for former Rowan County Clerk Kim Davis argue she didn’t intentionally hide or lie about an inheritance while under oath.
Last week, a federal judge ordered Davis to explain why she did not disclose an inheritance that is now the subject of a state lawsuit.
Davis garnered national attention in 2015 when she refused to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples on the grounds it violated her religious beliefs. Her denials were ruled unconstitutional.
In 2023, a federal jury ruled Davis owed $100,000 in damages to one of those couples: David Moore and David Ermold. After attorneys fees and court expenses, that amount is now north of $560,000.
Earlier this year, the couple accused Davis in Rowan Circuit Court of lying under oath about what properties and assets she owned in order to avoid paying.
The lawsuit notes Davis and her brother, Darold Rayburn Bailey Jr., inherited a $735,230 property from their late mother last year, and Davis transferred her share of the property to her brother, a sister-in-law, husband and son between April and May 2025.
The cash value of Davis’ share is more than $200,000, according to court filings.
U.S. Magistrate Judge Edward Atkins ruled that property and the transfers fell squarely in line with required disclosures and ordered Davis to explain why they weren’t mentioned. Atkins declined to hold her in contempt court, however.
In that court-ordered response filed Monday, Davis’ attorneys say she didn’t knowingly give any false statements at a post-trial hearing and didn’t intend to deceive or hide anything.
They also argue she transferred her share according to her late mother’s wishes and never intended to keep it.
“If my understanding was incorrect or mistaken, my answers were not given out of any intent to deceive or to be untruthful, but rather were the product of my understanding at the time I provided my answers and my understanding even now,” Davis said in written testimony.
She could still face monetary sanctions.