The Lexington-Fayette Urban County Council approved a zone change Tuesday night that will make way for a 99-unit apartment complex in the Hamburg area, despite criticism during a lengthy public hearing.
City officials say the development is needed, in part, because Lexington faces a shortage of roughly 22,000 housing units.
RAK Properties, the developer, wants to build the complex on a vacant parcel of land near the Tuscany subdivision. It would include a pair of two-story buildings, three with three stories and one central office building on a 4.7-acre lot.
The property at 2501 Sir Barton Way is vacant and was originally platted for office space in 2002.
“This is one of those properties that has been cited back and forth over the last quarter-century, as a matter of fact, as being a vacant property that can be a solution to the housing deficit we have in Lexington right now,” Dick Murphy, who represented the developer, told council members Tuesday at the panel’s regular meeting in chambers.
The proposal initially got a mixed reception from the city’s planning commission, which voted 4-4 in July to recommend the zoning change, followed by a 7-2 affirmative vote in August. As such, the council made the final call, with just one member opposed.
City planning staff recommend the commission not approve the zoning on the grounds the property would be accessed through a single point of ingress and egress, away from public roadways. It would be located off a small access road between the nearby WesBanco and Truist banks.
Neighbors who spoke Tuesday agreed.
“A single point of access off a private easement is not merely a design shortcoming. It's a public safety question about how emergency vehicles reach 100 households and how those hundred households can leave when something goes wrong,” Jessica Winters, a lawyer for a group of neighbors opposed to the zone change, told council members.
Some nearby residents also voiced concerns about how development could strain the neighborhood, increase light and noise pollution and drive down property values.
“Future development on the remaining properties behind our neighborhood could bring those same impacts directly behind my home, and if that happens, I may have to ask myself whether this is a place I still want to live and call home,” Tuscany neighbor Karen Hendren said.
The council opted to approve the zone change, however, with members noting the city faces a critical shortage of housing that could be addressed through such projects.
“The argument against it is rooted in what would be colloquially referred to as NIMBYism,” District 4 council member Emma Curtis said, referring to an acronym for “not in my backyard.”
“Quite literally, some of the testimony that we have heard was, 'We don't want this because it is in our backyards,’” she continued.
The zone change overwhelmingly passed with 12 yes votes. Lisa Higgins-Hord, who represents District 6, where the project is set to be built, cast the sole no vote.
District 2’s Shayla Lynch and District 7’s Joseph Hale were absent.